Stars, Language, Worldviews


One of my pet peeves is language that says the Sun moves around Earth. Words carry meaning, and if we reinforce long-disproven concepts, we stay stuck in centuries past — scientifically, socially, and religiously.

What follows will offer some alternatives — and, I hope, some food for thought and reflection. Before reading, think for a minute about how you would describe what is pictured here:

A Summer Sunrise over on the Nature Conservancy's Tallgrass Prairie Preserve near Pawhuska,Oklahoma<br />

Here’s how Marilynne Robinson has her protagonist describe it in her Pulitzer-prize-winning novel Gilead:

“This morning a splendid dawn passed over our house on its way to Kansas. This morning Kansas rolled out of its sleep into a sunlight grandly announced, proclaimed throughout heaven — one more of the very finite number of days that this old prairie has been called Kansas, or Iowa. But it has all been one day, that first day. Light is constant, we just turn over in it. So every day is in fact the selfsame evening and morning.”

Wow! Your reaction to that?

Here’s what I wrote years ago, in “Matins,” (Matins):
fql1od“ …
Slowly, slowly (or so it seems) Earth rotates,
revealing a brilliant, blinding star
so distant that its million multiples
of Earth’s size seem
a solitary shining footlight on the horizon.
…. ”

While we’re remembering that our sun-star neither rises nor sets, try these last ten lines of Katy Didden’s poem ”Before Edison Invented Lights” (in The Glacier’s Wake) [Painting by Mary Southward, CSJ]:
“ …
When you sleep with your face to the sky
untitledthe stars are not so much above
as around you. Stare long enough
and you begin to feel
you could lift your body off the earth
and hover in the black night
on the web of your awe
at a billion suns
toward which
everything you’re made of yearns.”

Wow, again! And why does everything we’re made of yearn for the suns? Curt Stager answers in Your Atomic Self, from the chapter “Fires of Life”:

“To look into the night sky is to survey distant gardens in which the elements of life are ripening, and your body is a composite harvest from these cosmic fields. Throughout history, people have spoken of the earth as our mother and the sun as our father … In an atomic sense, however, it would be more accurate to think of the earth and the sun as our siblings, because they both formed from the same star debris as the elements of life within us. Earth is indeed a kind of surrogate mother to us in that our bodies are derived from it, but we exist today only because our true celestial star mothers died long ago.”

Neil de Grasse Tyson echoes that reality: “The spectacular truth encoded in your DNA is that the very atoms of your body were initially forged in long-dead stars. This is why, when we look at the sky with wonder and longing, we feel some ineffable tugging at our innards. We are star stuff.”

Language and Worldviews

As for changing language, Stager writes “Simply replacing the word “sun” with “star” can change your sense of what this sylvan scene actually is. Lie flat on your back on the warm wood of a dock, and it may further dispel the normal illusion that the great fireball is “up there in the sky” instead of “right over there beside us in space.” Something about being horizontal and seeing the sun-star before you rather than above your head makes it easier to sense the absence of supporting pedestals or cables and therefore to realize that the brilliant, life-sustaining heart of our solar system floats in emptiness as it directs the trembling of your atoms from millions of miles away.”

It’s easy — though sloppy — to perpetuate a faulty philosophy by using words that belong to an obsolete flat-earth worldview. It can be disorienting to realize that we are one planet orbiting one of the billions of suns in our galaxy, and that our galaxy is one among billions. It almost hurts to get one’s head around the truth of where we are! But, to quote Stager again:

“The task that we face now is … to more closely attune our worldviews to the fascinating reality that Earth-orbiting telescopes, atom-probing microscopes, and other complex inventions have only recently uncovered for us. … How amazing to exist at all and how important it is, as our numbers and know-how increase, that we and our descendants develop such awareness as best we can.”

Language, Worldviews, and Believers

Is it important for believers? Ask St. Thomas Aquinas, who wrote: “A mistake about creation will lead to a mistake about God.” Ask Fr. Sean McDonagh: “We must continually learn from science, evolve our theology, and humbly situate ourselves in the wider Creation story.”

What have you learned from science about our place and our meaning in the cosmos — including our role in caring for our precious common home? Replies welcome!

Note: Christians who wish to ponder Light this Advent, alone or with others, might consider using Advent 2016: In Praise of Light: advent-2016.

7 thoughts on “Stars, Language, Worldviews

  1. St. Thomas Aquinas is the one who boldly wrote, “It gets warmer, the farther south you journey. If you were to voyage far enough south, you would burst into flame.”
    The number of mistakes about creation in that unfounded, unresearched claim probably had even God chuckling. 😯


  2. thanks for this! just shared out on twitter with this Q: Edison’s lights, longing for starry sky and myth…Reason why some humans desire SpaceX travel? 🙂 will share in today’s post as well..

    also will greatly appreciate your review of this piece on the Christian ‘eating the knowledge of good and evil’ myth:

    love and hugs, m

    Megan Hollingsworth

    ex·tinc·tion wit·ness writer & creative director

    I Call You Orlando – poem voiced

    On Tue, Oct 4, 2016 at 8:12 PM, ecospirituality resources wrote:

    > terrishcj posted: “Stars One of my pet peeves is language that says the > Sun moves around Earth. Words carry meaning, and if we reinforce > long-disproven concepts, we stay stuck in centuries past — scientifically, > socially, and religiously. What follows will offer some al” >

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thoroughly enjoyed your quotes and the new language – wonderful examples of just how to change the cosmology. .. now, maybe you’ll play with me for a moment. I wonder what difference this new consciousness might make in the future? How might an understanding of ourselves as starstuff, of planet as sibbling, of sun as star, of space as neighbourhood change our relationship to one another or earth, to our atmosphere, biosphere, to other Earthlings. I wonder would it bring an end to the colonial mindset, the economic powers, the competitive politics…. Thanks Terry, I greatly appreciate your work and having a cosmic playmate.


    • Thanks for your great comments, Carol! I used to think that understanding our place would be an automatic door people could pass through and have those wonderful results that you list (and others that we try to achieve). I now believe that knowledge is essential but not sufficient. Love has to be included, too. Different personality types need different doors, but everyone I know, or know about, who cares about our common home really loves it and each of its interconnected components. That said, I still believe it’s important to leave an obsolete worldview in order to shed mental frameworks that applaud destructive dominance and unhealthy competition and isolation. I didn’t start out feeling the unity of creation, so I know it takes time. Is Gaiafarmhouse in CA? Anyone connected with anything named “Gaia” is fostering the unity we could not have realized a century ago; let’s keep the play going! Blessings!


Leave a Reply to Carol Kilby Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s